Learn more
These promotions will be applied to this item:
Some promotions may be combined; others are not eligible to be combined with other offers. For details, please see the Terms & Conditions associated with these promotions.
Audiobook Price: $17.72$17.72
Save: $8.23$8.23 (46%)
Your Memberships & Subscriptions

Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Women's Work: A Reckoning with Work and Home Kindle Edition
From National Book Award finalist Megan K. Stack, a stunning memoir of raising her children abroad with the help of Chinese and Indian women who are also working mothers
When Megan Stack was living in Beijing, she left her prestigious job as a foreign correspondent to have her first child and work from home writing a book. She quickly realized that caring for a baby and keeping up with the housework while her husband went to the office each day was consuming the time she needed to write. This dilemma was resolved in the manner of many upper-class families and large corporations: she availed herself of cheap Chinese labor. The housekeeper Stack hired was a migrant from the countryside, a mother who had left her daughter in a precarious situation to earn desperately needed cash in the capital. As Stack's family grew and her husband's job took them to Dehli, a series of Chinese and Indian women cooked, cleaned, and babysat in her home. Stack grew increasingly aware of the brutal realities of their lives: domestic abuse, alcoholism, unplanned pregnancies. Hiring poor women had given her the ability to work while raising her children, but what ethical compromise had she made?
Determined to confront the truth, Stack traveled to her employees' homes, met their parents and children, and turned a journalistic eye on the tradeoffs they'd been forced to make as working mothers seeking upward mobility—and on the cost to the children who were left behind.
Women's Work is an unforgettable story of four women as well as an electrifying meditation on the evasions of marriage, motherhood, feminism, and privilege.

Explore your book, then jump right back to where you left off with Page Flip.
View high quality images that let you zoom in to take a closer look.
Enjoy features only possible in digital – start reading right away, carry your library with you, adjust the font, create shareable notes and highlights, and more.
Discover additional details about the events, people, and places in your book, with Wikipedia integration.
Customers who bought this item also bought
Editorial Reviews
Review
—Kate Tuttle, The Boston Globe
"Memoirs about motherhood are exceedingly common, but Women’s Work dares to explore the labor arrangements that often make such books possible . . . Stack writes sharp, pointed sentences that flash with dark insight . . . [A] fearless book."
—Jennifer Szalai, The New York Times
"Probing and fascinating. Stack doesn't shy away from describing her own feelings . . . Stack's writing is sharp and lovely."
—Erica Pearson, Minneapolis Star Tribune
“Megan Stack is willing to confront hard questions that many of us flinch from: about the relationships between women and the women we hire to take care of our houses and our children, to do the traditional women’s work that gives ‘liberated women’ the time to do traditional men’s work. Women’s Work is a book of vivid characters, engrossing stories, shrewd insights, and uncomfortable reflections.”
—Anne-Marie Slaughter, author of Unfinished Business and president and CEO of New America
“Women’s Work hit me where I live, and I haven’t been able to stop thinking about it. Stack uses her reporting acumen to illuminate domestic workers’ struggles, but also fearlessly reveals the most vulnerable details of her own life in order to make her point. The masterfulness with which she tells these intertwined stories makes this book not just a work of brilliant journalism but a work of art.”
—Emily Gould, author of And the Heart Says Whatever and Friendship
“If Karl Ove Knausgaard himself were a woman and had given birth, he might have written a book a little like Women’s Work. Megan Stack’s mastery of language and attention to detail make magic of the most quotidian aspects of life.”
—Barbara Demick, author of Nothing to Envy: Ordinary Lives in North Korea
“A fierce and furious and darkly funny book about the costs of motherhood: the psychological costs, the costs in time and energy and spirit, and finally the costs imposed on other women, most of them also mothers, who leave their own children so they can take care of ours. I can’t think of a work that speaks more directly to our age of increasing inequality, starting with housework and child care, the oldest inequalities of all.”
—Keith Gessen, author of A Terrible Country
“Megan Stack obliterates the silence that upholds one of our greatest taboos: our universal reliance on domestic labor that women—women of color especially—are expected to supply freely or cheaply. With journalistic rigor, Stack centers the complicated lives of women who clean our homes and care for our children, but it’s her willingness to shine a light into the dark, typically untouched corners of her own family, privilege, and ambition that makes this book soar.”
—Angela Garbes, author of Like a Mother: A Feminist Journey through the Science and Culture of Pregnancy
About the Author
Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.
How to Disappear
Chapter 1
It was a Tuesday morning and Tom was packing to leave me. He was headed out into the hinterlands, to a small town in south China where the Communist Party was cracking down on rioting factory workers. This was Tom’s kind of adventure—a trip out into the provinces, into The Real China, to witness a fracture in the power of the Party. A substantial assignment with a light dusting of adrenaline.
As for me, I was just trying to get comfortable. I experimented with pressing my spine straight against the floorboards, then raising my pelvis into the air. I sighed and groaned.
Rolling clothes into logs and stacking them upright in his backpack, Tom pointedly ignored me.
“Are you really OK with going on this trip?” I asked churlishly.
“Come on,” he smiled at me. “You’re not due for two more weeks.”
“That means anytime from right now.” With a heave I rolled over to my side, letting the heavy sac of water and child splash dully onto the floor.
“The doctor said you’ll probably be late,” he pointed out cheerfully. “I bet it’ll be three more weeks.”
“You don’t know.” No, that wasn’t comfortable, either. I pulled air into my lungs and held it, trying to push my ribs off my womb.
“There are flights every hour.”
I sighed. The baby punched. He had to come out, somehow. My flesh stood in the way of his life. Tissue would tear, blood must flow, pain was a promise.
“I’m going to the airport straight from the office,” Tom dropped a kiss on my hair. “Text me and tell me what the doctor says.”
“Don’t go.” I was too hot to think straight. I begrudged him, in some confused way, the airports and adventures that I had relinquished. Maybe I sensed that our fates were about to diverge radically; maybe I was trying, clumsily, to make him share my inconvenience and immobilization. Maybe I just wanted a companion, my love, the baby’s father. Maybe I was scared.
“Honey,” he said. “I can’t sit here for four weeks.”
And he went.
*
“Your fluid is too low,” the doctor announced the next day. “He has to come out right away.”
“What?” She might as well have said I was pregnant with a kangaroo kid. The indignation I had unloaded on Tom was, at bottom, an empty flourish of spousal guilt. Never for a moment had I believed the birth was imminent. “Why is the fluid low? What do you mean, right away?”
“The fluid is low because he’s not peeing. That means he’s not getting nourished. This can happen with gestational diabetes. The placenta sometimes stops working.”
I was numb, trying to follow. Then a spike of horror.
“He’s starving?”
“He’s not starving,” she said gently. “But he does need to come out now.”
“My husband isn’t here. I mean he’s traveling.”
She squinted at the ultrasound report, pen on her lips. “Can he be here tomorrow?”
“Yes.” Goddamn right he can. “Are you sure it’s okay to wait?”
“One day is OK. Go home. Take a long walk. Hopefully you’ll go into labor and we won’t need to induce.”
“So I’ll have the baby tomorrow.”
“If not tomorrow then Friday.”
“But the baby is coming now. Like, this week.”
“Yes.” She was laughing at me.
I called Tom, too shocked to be smug. Then, alone in the apartment, I started calling friends. I’m having the baby tomorrow. Repeating the words, I tried to make myself believe it was true.
I hadn’t packed a suitcase. Most pregnant women pack for the delivery months in advance. Checklists clutter the Internet: Soft pillow, relaxing music, favorite chocolate. But I, who had thrown together hundreds of suitcases for all manner of climates and crises, who had once kept a “go-bag” stuffed into my office closet for the next suicide bombing—I had never faced the ritual of packing this one, particular bag.
The baby was coming. I wasn’t ready. Tom wasn’t here. The entire enterprise was slipping off track.
I can no longer remember why this seemed important at the time, but during my pregnancy I’d become obsessed with the idea of a natural birth. I wanted to push my baby into the world through the vagina and without drugs. I told myself that I was a writer and an artist, a woman unbound by fear and pain and convention. I wanted the undiluted experience.
I knew everything about birth, or so I thought. Of course, I knew nothing about birth then, and I know nothing now. I only know that the only people who know anything about birth are women who are in the act. Like all great pain, like every altered state, it can only be apprehended from within. It can’t be anticipated or remembered.
I thought birth would be the texture of the soil; the color of the moon. I thought labor would be simple work. I thought pain would not be pain. In my imagination, it was like that.
I didn’t stop to consider that a truly “natural” birth would probably consist of a teenaged mother facing a decent chance of death, nor that there had been nothing natural about my pregnancy so far. I’d staved off motherhood with birth control while I built my career, only to discover that I needn’t have bothered. Pregnancy eluded me until I flew halfway around the world to undergo surgery for endometriosis.
A thirty-five-year-old frame stiffened and battered by decades of hard living and neglect, my body was hardly the youthful web of flexible ligament and muscle that biology would favor as its maternal vessel. “Advanced maternal age,” the doctor had written across the top of my file.
Nor was my temperament suited to natural birth. I’m a runner and an insomniac, not a yogi or meditator. I’d distinguished myself as the least relaxed mother in the Hypnobirthing class I’d attended with Tom in tow. The midwife had rolled her eyes and clicked her tongue over my tensed shoulders, so I ground my teeth and tried even harder to relax. I tried, really I did, and somehow that was part of the problem. I didn’t know how to stop trying.
During all this moony preparation, I hardly thought about the baby at all. This new human life was a misty idea, a blurred bundle of my own emotion wrapped in an impossibly fluffy blanket which, come to think of it, I didn’t own.
It was a lot to think about. Maybe this is how our contemporary psychology confronts massive change. Couples drown out a fear of lifelong commitment by obsessing over iris-and-ivy centerpieces and the vocabulary of the vows. Who wants to think about diapering and colic when you can sip chamomile tea with beatific pregnant ladies and swap tactical advice designed to outmaneuver the dreaded obstetrician? (“They’re surgeons, you know. They think it’s their job to cut you open.”)
I approached birth with the competitive, adrenalized mentality of hard-charging newspaper work. Labor was an arena in which I would struggle and—inevitably, eventually—triumph. I would do it. Me. Motherhood itself lurked out in the margins of an old map, scribbled with sea creatures. Here be dragons.
Tom struggled to get home. Thunderstorms raged in southern China that night. His flight lingered for hours on the runway. Hunched over his computer, dripping sweat, he hammered the interviews into a news story. Finally the plane took off into the night sky, carrying my husband north.
Harried and soggy and exultant, he reached our apartment at 3 am. I was lying in bed, wide awake.
Four hours later, we drank a pot of coffee and took a taxi to the hospital.
*
A cot with bars and perfectly white sheets. Instruments with dials and screens, steel tables, metallic skeletons and hooks, things that rolled away. A pullout sofa for Tom.
I kicked off my shoes and climbed onto the bed, but lying there felt like an affectation. Hospitals are for broken bones, surgery, stitches. Now I felt, obscurely, that I was making much of myself, swanning around on a perfectly normal Thursday morning.
“What are we going to do all day?” I asked Tom.
I kept looking at him and thinking, You should be at work! I think I even said it once: “This could take a while. I could call you.”
“Don’t be ridiculous,” he said.
I hated the bars that made the hospital bed resemble a cage. They delineated the man from the woman, the mother from the father. I malingered in plastic and metal and hospital pajamas. Tom sat with his exhausted complexion and street clothes. I wanted Tom to find it strange, too, but he didn’t share my agitation. When I fretted over the bars he frowned. “They’re just for—you know, physical safety,” he said absentmindedly.
If he realized we’d been split from one another, he didn’t mind. Maybe he had been raised to expect it; maybe I had not. The memory of those bars would stay in my mind for years.
The doctor came. The doctor frowned.
“The baby has not dropped,” she said. “The head is not engaged. Your cervix is closed.”
She tucked her clipboard under her arm and looked into my face.
“This induction is not going to be easy for you,” she said. “I know you wanted a natural birth, but under these circumstances I recommend an optional C-section.”
This was precisely what the midwife had warned us to expect—the doctor wanted to medicalize my birth!
“I don’t want a C-section,” I snapped. “But you said it’s ‘optional,’ right? I have a choice?”
“Ye-e-s,” she said slowly. “I can’t say it’s imperative. Not yet. So, of course, it is your choice.”
“Then no,” I said firmly. “No C-section.”
“Fine,” she said. “We’ll start by trying to soften your cervix and start contractions. Then we’ll see how it goes.”
*
The summer day pressed upon the hospital and the city, pressed upon my belly with an immobile and dull ache. We pestered and pressed the nurses for permission to go for a walk. Getting out of the maternity ward was like getting out of prison. Forms were signed; promises extracted; bracelets issued.
The drab side streets of northern Beijing offered no promising place to stroll. The sidewalk came and went in unhelpful patches. We passed faded dusty storefronts and stalls hung with crutches and stale bandages and flimsy wheelchairs folded like dinosaur skeletons. A chain Italian restaurant, heaps of fruit, laundry. All was pavement and towers and walls, all was mineral hard surface.
“Let’s go in here,” I said. “It looks like there’s some kind of playground or park—”
“It’s a workers’ compound,” Tom said. “They built these all over China. All the people who live here will have worked for the same factory or ministry or whatever.”
Through a rusting gate we entered a constellation of brick apartments. Old men played mah jong at picnic tables, shuffling their tiles, cupping their hands over cigarettes. A sweaty day, sky clotted with smog, air thick with coming rain. The young and the elderly had fled cramped quarters for the cracked pavement and weedy beds of the courtyard. Clusters of women bent their heads together and children roamed wild. There was a miniature amusement park with a tiny merry-go-round, sun-faded plastic animals, a trampoline. An old man took coins for the rides. Only one small girl had pocket money; she spun alone and serious, as if she’d done this ride before and it was never what she’d hoped. The old man hawked and spat. Soon her turn would end.
“We won’t be able to get out this way,” Tom warned.
“There must be a second gate.”
“These compounds usually have only one way in and one way out,” he said. “But we can try.”
“Okay.” I kept walking.
Our path was shrinking; the buildings closed around us. I led us down one alley, then another, but each one was a dead end.
Tom was right.
“You were right,” I told him.
“It’s not about who’s right,” he said.
Forward momentum hit the wall. We could only return, retreat and go back to where we had started.
*
Back in the hospital room, painful contractions gripped and vanished in pointless rhythms. The hours dragged along but the baby didn’t budge.
A nurse tucked sheets over Tom’s sofa bed. I crawled in beside him, sluggish and sick, and twisted in contractions until sunrise.
Morning brought breakfast trays and yellow light. Smog stood thick in the air. In the schoolyard behind the hospital, children sang their morning anthems to the Communist Party and then counted off their exercise drills. I had been in the hospital for 24 hours and practically nothing had happened. Morning fell to afternoon and sunset clotted into black but still the baby stuck high. Another night in wakeful limbo. Too much pain to sleep and yet I was desperate for more pain, enough pain to tear this baby, once and for all, from my body. In the morning the doctors urged me, again, to have a C-section, and again I refused. With grim, we-tried-to-warn-you faces, they hooked a sack of Pitocin to the IV and flooded my veins with birth hormones.
I had been stultified and swollen, but now my body began to shift around with excruciating speed. I distinctly felt my hipbones dragging themselves apart. The sensation reminded me of the rack, of hapless medieval lieutenants drawn and quartered, horses pounding in opposite directions to spill hot blood on stinking dust. Torture, execution, European history—God! I didn’t want any of that in my head. I had expected some tearing and stretching, but this sensation was deeper and deadlier and unspeakably painful. My skeleton was being dismantled. There was nothing in my brain but gruesome images and a single mantra: I am going to die.
I was supposed to be thinking of other things. The midwife had trained us to meditate and “go to a place deep inside,” as one of the hippy moms had described birth. But it wasn’t happening. I had been awake for two days straight and my strength was blown and that place inside of me, if indeed it existed, was not findable now.
The hospital room had disintegrated into its own drabness. I rolled far out at sea, in the fogged dark of night, and the waves pushed and tossed and I couldn’t keep my head above water. I’m here, I’m lost, let me go. Another life is buried within me. It is also my life. My own life must rip itself from my center and leave me dead. Let them take it. Let me go. His life, my life. Take it, do it. I can’t anymore.
“Give me an epidural,” I gasped when I could speak again.
The contractions were fast.
The needle was huge.
I couldn’t have cared less.
“You have to stay still, even when the contractions are coming,” the doctor warned. “If the needle slips you can be paralyzed.”
Cold steel slipping quick oh God that’s my spine. I was still at sea but now it sloshed with the sweetness of nothing. I was too limp to talk. “I’ll take a shower,” Tom said uncertainly.
“You should,” I agreed. He withdrew into the bathroom and I heard the slap of water on tiles. I luxuriated in nothingness.
But something was happening. Monitors beeped, buzzers bellowed, nurses raced in from the hall. Suddenly the room was crammed with people rushing, chattering, flipping pages.
“You’re going into surgery,” somebody shouted. “The baby’s heart is failing.”
“One, two, THREE!” They heaved me onto a stretcher. Tom came dripping and bewildered from the bathroom, and then he was running beside me, somebody had given him a cap and a mask, somebody had given him scrubs. I was losing moments. I understood what was happening and I understood that it was happening to me. It had already happened a very long time ago. It was a memory in real time.
The surgery was freezing cold and snappingly bright. Nausea rolled and curdled.
“I’m going to throw up,” I whispered to Tom. “I don’t know how—”
“We’ve already cut you open,” a nurse barked. “No moving. I’ll put a towel under your chin and you vomit there.”
I did as I was told.
I heard a baby crying.
Product details
- ASIN : B07FBZCX38
- Publisher : Anchor (April 2, 2019)
- Publication date : April 2, 2019
- Language : English
- File size : 3.4 MB
- Text-to-Speech : Enabled
- Screen Reader : Supported
- Enhanced typesetting : Enabled
- X-Ray : Enabled
- Word Wise : Enabled
- Print length : 339 pages
- Best Sellers Rank: #1,532,382 in Kindle Store (See Top 100 in Kindle Store)
- #1,557 in Motherhood (Kindle Store)
- #1,774 in Asian & Asian American Biographies
- #2,477 in Culinary Biographies & Memoirs
- Customer Reviews:
About the author

Discover more of the author’s books, see similar authors, read book recommendations and more.
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers find the book enjoyable and appreciate its insights into early motherhood. The writing style receives mixed reactions from customers.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Select to learn more
Customers find the book enjoyable, with one mentioning it works well for women's book clubs.
"...looks at this question and so much more, in a highly personal and enjoyable way." Read more
"...Ultimately though, despite the unlikeability of the narrator, I enjoyed the book...." Read more
"...This would be a wonderful book for a women's book club...especially women who have nannies, maids, cleaning women, yard folks, etc...." Read more
"I really loved this book...." Read more
Customers find the book insightful, particularly regarding early motherhood, with one customer noting how it resonates with mothers in the US.
"...is how these stories set half way around the world, would resonate with mothers in the US...." Read more
"...guilt, frustrated ambition and boredom are tangible, and made the book an engaging read. I would recommend it." Read more
"I really loved this book. It gives a perspective on early motherhood and how challenging and conflicting it is for someone who is so passionate..." Read more
"...It's such a shame because clearly this is a topic worthy of attention...." Read more
Customers have mixed opinions about the author's style, with some finding it poetic while others criticize it as self-absorbed.
"...It moved fast and painted a vivid picture of what her life was like in two rarefied global environments-- her guilt, frustrated ambition and boredom..." Read more
"...Stack's vulnerability brings this struggle to life. This book reads like a novel. I had a hard time putting it down...." Read more
"...I was prepared to dislike this book especially since the author is quite neurotic and tends to whine. However, I loved the book!..." Read more
"...At first, I found the author's writing to be inviting. I appreciated her honesty...." Read more
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.
- Reviewed in the United States on July 3, 2019As someone who lived and raised a family overseas for over a decade, the topic of this book immediately caught my attention. I grappled with my own choices about working in a challenging full-time career and being home to raise my children; as women around the world do everyday. Like Ms. Stack, I had the opportunity to take advantage of plentiful inexpensive domestic help thanks to my geographic location. I could personally relate to so much that Megan so bravely shares with her readers and I found myself whole heartedly agreeing with the trials she went through as a mom raising kids so far from your family.
What I was more surprised about is how these stories set half way around the world, would resonate with mothers in the US. Even if it is not as common to have full time domestic help, American mothers also struggle with so many difficult choices that fathers never have to make. This book covers such a deeply personal yet universal situation that you do not even need to have children of your own to understand how society has to take a much deeper look at the importance of providing new parents a better way to balance work and home life. This looks at this question and so much more, in a highly personal and enjoyable way.
- Reviewed in the United States on July 3, 2019I admit that I went into this book with my hackles up, but wound up liking it quite a lot. Her description of childbirth, of her evocation of the sucking, sleepless vortex that follows it is the most realistic that I've read - in fact, I'm giving the book to a professional dad whose wife is expecting, so he can get a sense of what they're in for.
But that is the where the "universality" of her experience ended. This is not at all a book about "women's work." This is a book about one extremely privileged, navel-gazing white woman who can afford to hire boundless domestic labor while she spends four (or five?) years working intermittently on a novelistic vanity project that -- she insists -- should be taken just as seriously as her husband's remunerated labor. But the novel is not successful, and she begins to imagine a sort of solidarity between herself and the impoverished women she hires: they are all them, after all, doing "women's work," and the burden of it is preventing all of them from doing what they really want to do. Her construction of herself as a partner in her servant's labors involves pages on pages of description about how tiring and nettlesome her domestic life is. (We are expected to forget how much more tiring her life would be if she were, say, living back in the US and doing her own housework.) It also involves casting her husband as the villain of the piece -- he's the disconnected dad who has the privilege of an interrupted professional life because all of these women are carrying his domestic load. The foundational conceit of the books is that, because Ms Stack was professionally disadvantaged by childrearing relative to her husband, she was somehow on the same spectrum as the brutalized women she hired. I was not convinced.
I grew up abroad with nannies. But as an affluent career woman living in the US, I found little to identify with here. When I hired a nanny, it consumed most of my take-home pay and bought very little: no housework, no weekend help: just gap-year girls who spent most of their time watching tv. By the end of the book, it becomes hard to listen to this pampered creature's bellyaching. Her voyeurism and intrusiveness towards her employees is also, frankly, alarming: she stalks them on Facebook, she noses constantly and unwholesomely into their business... all in the name of her "journalistic" intentions and her desire to "empathize" with them. Golly: if they were American nannies, I'm sure they could have sued for harassment. She must have been a god-awful employer. Her household comes across as a reality show just waiting to happen.
Ultimately though, despite the unlikeability of the narrator, I enjoyed the book. It moved fast and painted a vivid picture of what her life was like in two rarefied global environments-- her guilt, frustrated ambition and boredom are tangible, and made the book an engaging read. I would recommend it.
- Reviewed in the United States on April 15, 2019As a lawyer in her mid-thirties who wants to soon start a family, I have thought about about the compromises that are folded into that choice. Megan Stack writes beautifully about the tension of buying the time of less privileged women so that the careers and households of the more privileged can thrive. It is a wrenching and fraught situation. Stack's vulnerability brings this struggle to life. This book reads like a novel. I had a hard time putting it down. A thank you to the author for sharing this part of her life.
- Reviewed in the United States on January 24, 2020After reading Women’s Work, A Reckoning With Work and Home by Megan K. Stack, I debated whether to even review it for BoomerBroadcast. If I don’t particularly enjoy a book, I usually don’t finish it, but the excellent writing compelled me to keep going, despite the fact I did not like the author or her message. I’ll review it anyway and if any of you read it, you might have a completely different take on it.
First of all, the title is misleading. I thought I was embarking on an overview of the work/life balance faced by so many working women today. What I found was someone pretending to have the same challenges as other working mothers, but is so self-centred and narrow-minded that I struggled to sympathize with the perceived challenges of her life.
Megan Stack is an American journalist who is experienced in reporting from war zones and foreign countries—kind of a new-age Murphy Brown. While working in China with her husband, who is also a journalist, she becomes pregnant and finds her adult-only, self-centred life turned upside down. With the easy availability of cheap domestic labour and trying to maintain her career as a writer, she decides to hire a Chinese nanny/housekeeper following the birth of her son. She naively imagines continuing her writing career while the ‘help’ takes care of domestic chores and babysitting.
This is when Stack’s world implodes. After a difficult delivery, she’s physically drained and finds it challenging to cope with her new role. Her new baby is fussy and discontented. Despite having domestic help, she’s unable to rebuild the daily life she had envisioned—cuddling her new baby and being productive writing her novel while the baby sleeps. Domestic help comes with its own set of challenges. Does she trust the woman looking after her child? How much should she get involved in this woman’s personal problems? How much extra financial support should she dole out?
Stack’s husband has the advantage of going out each morning to an office or on assignments that keep him out of the line of fire. This arrangement only serves to inflame Megan Stack’s resentment of her husband and exacerbates his hands-off behaviour. No one is happy with the new lifestyle.
Then, when Stack is pregnant with their second child, her husband is transferred to Delhi, India. Domestic labour is even cheaper there and she hires two women to do the cooking, cleaning and childcare while she writes. Sounds simple enough but it’s not. Her domestic problems with her help have literally doubled. One lady travels across the city an a series of buses to work and the second one lives in quarters behind the main house. Stack still cannot cope and whines when her ladies want to take a Sunday off.
Obviously, Megan Stack can write. She’s a journalist and her writing skill is what kept me reading even though I thoroughly disliked her and her husband. It’s impossible to forecast what any one of us would do in similar circumstances but the whole time she’s whining about her staff problems and her inability to keep her writing career on track, I found myself wondering what she would do if she had to face the same challenges so many less affluent new mothers are faced with.
How can she complain when there are so many single mothers out there trying to simply put food on the table and pay the rent by working menial, low-income jobs, often without husbands much less the advantage of domestic help? What about abused women? Her lack of perspective left me frustrated and angry, even though she claims to be on the side of those ‘other women’.
It’s not the fault of the author that the content is not what I expected. It was not an objective overview of the unbalanced gender-based distribution of domestic work to women. It was the experience of one woman delegating domestic work to her own employees in her own home. Since the beginning of time, women have been victims of our biology. We’re the ones who have the babies and are expected to shoulder a disproportionate amount of time for childcare and homemaking. Because of this, we will never have the same freedom from domestic drudgery that men enjoy.
When the novel she was working on wasn’t picked up by a publisher, Stack resorted to the handiest bit of research and experience she could access. She used the three women who had been in her employ to create Women’s Work, a case study of working women but it’s not of our larger world. I did empathize with these women, and their stories, which unfolded at the end of the book, made it worthwhile finishing.
So many women and mothers face unimaginable struggles every single day of their lives. How could the author imagine her life even compares? Stack’s personal story was annoying and frustrating, but the stories of her three domestic helpers were definitely worth the read. The quality of the writing is definitely 9 out 10 but the author’s ability to get me on side with her personal story was much, much lower. I’d be curious to know if you agree or disagree with me.
Top reviews from other countries
- GiuliaReviewed in Italy on January 15, 2020
5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent
A very good book
- SamReviewed in the United Kingdom on September 1, 2019
5.0 out of 5 stars Speechless..this book is phenomenal
I grew up as one of Megan's children in Latin America. I felt I was opening a window to my mother's life reading this book. I can't recommend it enough. If I could give it ten stars I would. Read it now!!
One person found this helpfulReport - jacqueline sarah bushnellReviewed in the United Kingdom on June 1, 2019
5.0 out of 5 stars Outstanding
Beautifully written and poignant. An exploration of uncomfortable truths conducted with compassion and humility. Thank you Megan for your insight.
One person found this helpfulReport